01

Make the scope equal

Give each supplier the same six vial dimensions, filled weights, cap types, card stack, artwork and intended distribution route. Specify 1,000 or more boxes per design. Ask whether each quote covers the sleeve or shell, tray or insert, card pocket, print, sample, setup and export packing. A lower box-only figure is not directly comparable to a packed-set quote.

02

Consider assembly and storage

A paperboard tray may arrive flat and need folding, insertion and vial loading at the packing location. A rigid drawer may arrive assembled, but its insert and cards can still require separate steps. Confirm how each component is delivered and who erects and packs it; do not infer labour time from a render.

Illustrative comparison: if one option requires two additional assembly operations for each of 1,000 sets, record those 2,000 operations in the packing plan and time a representative trial. This arithmetic is not a measured MTT labour result or an estimated cost.

03

Measure the complete shipment

Ask for the number of cartons, carton dimensions and gross weights for shells, trays and inserts separately. Calculate physical cubic metres for each carton size as outside length × width × height in metres × carton count, then sum the results. A carrier may charge on a different basis, so obtain comparable actual quotations for the same destination and service.

04

Review each loaded sample

Check sleeve travel, folded corners, insert retention, safe vial removal and card clearance for the paperboard concept. For a rigid drawer, compare the actual tray, pull and cavity layout; the existing four-vial concept shows a different count, so it is a structural reference rather than a like-for-like price comparison.

Discuss the complete outer pack and test requirements with the brand and laboratory. ISTA distinguishes an early screening test from tests designed around distribution environments.[1]

05

Decide with a common checklist

Record the approved opening, product access, appearance, packing work, carton plan and delivery terms for each option. Confirm material, print, logo, sample charge and schedule on the actual specification. The broader rigid-versus-carton guide explains family differences; this comparison focuses on the same discovery-set brief.

06

A like-for-like quotation checklist

Keep the comparison on the same scope
Cost or taskQuestion for both suppliers
PackagingAre the tray, insert and card space included?
Set-upAre printing, die and sample charges separated?
AssemblyWho erects the box and loads the vials?
FreightAre destination, service and carton scope equivalent?

Use a representative assembly trial rather than a presumed labour rate. If the rigid and paperboard concepts use different vial counts, resize both around the same product brief before treating the quotations as alternatives. The displayed images are design references, not existing stock or a price promise.

07

Sources

  1. ISTA: packaged-product test procedure families, accessed 18 November 2026.